The Pokémon Review Thread: Generation 1 (22.5% Done)

Last edited by Jaco230 on Wed Oct 13, 2010 12:12 pm; edited 77 times in total

Alright, this is gonna be a HUGE thread, as long as jeffer keeps the character count at a lowdown.
In this thread I will review every single Pokémon there is, in order. Be aware that I am basing this 90% on looks/coolness, and 10% on usefulness,
which is pretty shallow, I know. But then again, I've never owned every Pokémon at once before, so I can't really do this that way.
Also, be aware that this thread is obviously going to be not finished yet. I'll try to get around adding 10 Pokémon reviews in every day, and see how it works.
I'll also add a userscore, which means that you guys can rate Pokémon, too, and I'll average all of your scores together, seperated from mine.
So, it'll looks like this:

My score : 7.5
Userscore: 6.0

I hope that made sense. Also, I will be using spoiler tags, so you won't have to scroll down so much.
Okay, let's do this.

Quote :

#001 Bulbasaur:

#002 Ivysaur:

#003 Venusaur:

#004 Charmander:

#005 Charmeleon:

#006 Charizard:

#007 Squirtle:

#008 Wartortle:

#009 Blastoise:

#010 Caterpie:

#011 Metapod:

#012 Butterfree:

#013 Weedle:

#014 Kakuna:

#015 Beedrill:

#016 Pidgey:

#017 Pidgeotto:

#018 Pidgeot:

#019 Rattata:

#020 Raticate:

#021 Spearow:

#022 Fearow:

#023 Ekans:

#024 Arbok:

#025 Pikachu:

#026 Raichu:

#027 Sandshrew:

#028 Sandslash:

#029 Nidoran♀:

#030 Nidorina:

#031 Nidoqueen:

#032 Nidoran♂:

#033 Nidorino:

#034 Nidoking:

#035 Clefairy:

#036 Clefable:

Pokemon Idol season 2. :O
I think you're missing a couple judges..

jefferlope wrote:: Pokemon Idol season 2. :O
I think you're missing a couple judges..

Heheh. Should I add a third score?

My score
User score
Judge score Cool

Posts : 2722 Join date : 2010-07-29 Age : 54

I'll just state my opinions each time you add new pokemon. I'll be more strict though, I just won't base it on appearance.
And Jaco, Squirtle owned a Machoke with bubbles, don't you remember the movie?

Quote :

#001 Bulbasaur:

#002 Ivysaur:

#003 Venusaur:

#004 Charmander:

#005 Charmeleon:

#006 Charizard:

#007 Squirtle:

#008 Wartortle:

#009 Blastoise:

#010 Caterpie:

#011 Metapod:

#012 Butterfree:

#013 Weedle:

#014 Kakuna:

#015 Beedrill:

#016 Pidgey:

#017 Pidgeotto:

#018 Pidgeot:

#019 Rattata:

#020 Raticate:

#021 Spearow:

#022 Fearow:

#023 Ekans:

#024 Arbok:

#025 Pikachu:

that must have taken forever good job

Posts : 2722 Join date : 2010-07-29 Age : 54

This is nothing yet. Wait till we get to the 50s if we ever do.

Or the 450's.
That'll be the day.

Posts : 2722 Join date : 2010-07-29 Age : 54

Jaco230 wrote:: Or the 450's.
That'll be the day.

Or the 500's maybe? THat'll be the day we'll get popular maybe.

I think you guys might wanna put it all in one big spoiler tag..

Posts : 2722 Join date : 2010-07-29 Age : 54

jefferlope wrote:: I think you guys might wanna put it all in one big spoiler tag..

Its all we can go. Maybe we should have different topics for every 50 or 100 pokemon.

jefferlope wrote:: I think you guys might wanna put it all in one big spoiler tag..

That's exactly what I wanted to do in the first place. But unfortunately, that ain't gonna fly.

MaxMatsu wrote:

jefferlope wrote:: I think you guys might wanna put it all in one big spoiler tag..

Its all we can go. Maybe we should have different topics for every 50 or 100 pokemon.

I'm thinking this is exactly what we're gonna do Max. We'll call this thread Part 1... The next Part 2... And so on. But we'll stop in increments... I don't know by how much, though.

Or, we can just screw it and put all 493 reviews in this very section. Like you said, scrolling ain't much of a problem.

Posts : 2722 Join date : 2010-07-29 Age : 54

Lol first double post.

And yeah, what I'm worried is that maybe the topic will be too long and you won't be actually able to post more words in it.

» Pokemon Thread
» BECAUSE THERE IS NO POETRY THREAD!
» Happy Thread
» ***OFFICIAL*** 3DS THREAD
» Venting thread